Otitis Externa Series Part 2: Topical Therapy for Otitis Externa
Colleen Mendelsohn, DVM, Diplomate ACVD, & Wayne Rosenkrantz, DVM, Diplomate ACVD
In Part 1 of this series—Diagnosis of Otitis Externa—the factors and causes of this disease, diagnostic testing and imaging, and ear cleaning and flushing were discussed. Visit tvpjournal.com to read this article, which was published in the September/October 2014 issue of Today’s Veterinary Practice.
Ear disease accounts for up to 15% of all canine veterinary case presentations.1,2Regardless of the primary cause of otitis externa, secondary infection treatment is usually the focus of therapy.
Otic preparations that address bacterial and/or yeast infections are usually combinations of antimicrobials and corticosteroids. The large number of commercial topical otic preparations reflects the demand for these products.
It is important to understand the underlying causes of otitis, as well as factors that contribute to the condition, in order to provide targeted therapy and effective treatment (Table 1).
|Table 1. Common Factors & Causes of Otitis Externa|
Otic cytology is an integral part of:
- Diagnosing otic disease
- Determining best treatment approach and maintenance protocol
- Assessing treatment success.
Otic cytology is inexpensive, highly informative, and easily self-taught. With practice, the practitioner can quickly become familiar with samples from inflammatory lesions, including recognition of:
- Yeast (Figure 1)
- Dermatophyte spores and hyphae (Figure 2)
- Other fungal conditions, such as aspergillosis or cryptococcosis
- Parasites (Figure 3)
- Foreign material (Figure 4).
Cytology is an integral part of therapy and needs to be performed throughout the treatment process to monitor and adjust your treatment. Part 1 of this article series provides more in-depth discussion of otic cytology.
General properties of topical otic formulations include 2 important components—the vehicle and the active ingredient.
Otic product vehicles have different properties that determine their efficacy in practice, and their functions include (Table 2):
- Promoting delivery of active ingredients
- Stabilizing active ingredients
- Determining drying or occlusive properties
- Modifying pH
- Adding factors, such as texture and fragrance, to enhance product pleasance.
However, product vehicles can have irritant properties, which must be taken into consideration.
|Table 2. Otic Formulation Vehicles|
|VEHICLE||INDICATIONS & CONTRAINDICATIONS|
|Creams Emulsions Ointments||
|Table 3. Otic Formulation Active Ingredients|
When a practitioner chooses a topical otic product, appropriate treatment for the patient’s specific condition, as well as the practitioner’s familiarity with the product, must be taken into consideration. Active ingredients of topical otic preparations are often combined to reach a desired effect (Table 3).
As described in Part 1 of this article series, ear cleaning is imperative for successful otitis therapy. In many cases, the ears should be thoroughly cleaned by the veterinarian, followed by owner administration of medications at home.
Excessive cleaning by clients can be a perpetuating factor in chronic recurrent otitis. Most cleansers should be used no more than 2 to 3 times weekly, and sometimes not at all. Frequency of cleaning is based on the amount of inflammation and degree of exudate, wax, or debris that is being produced, which depends on the primary condition and perpetuating factors.
When regular cleaning is imperative, consider the patient and type and amount of exudate. For example:
- In cases of chronic ceruminous otitis—most commonly seen in idiopathic seborrhea in cocker spaniels—regular ear cleaning and maintenance by the client is extremely important.
- In dogs with increased ceruminous (waxy) debris build-up, ceruminolytic action is desired (Table 4).3,6,7
- Drying cleansers can be used to prevent infection in “allergic” ears that tend to develop infections but are not severely exudative.
|Table 4. Veterinary Otic Formulations|
|AGENT||BRAND NAME||ACTIVITY & INDICATIONS|
|CLEANSERS & RINSES|
|Phytosphingosine||Douxo Micellar Solution (ceva.us)||
|Phytosphingosine||Douxo Micellar Solution (ceva.us)||See above|
|Spherulites (lactic acid and salicylic acid)||Epi-Otic Advanced(virbacvet.com)||
|Zinc (boric acid)||Maxi/Guard Zn4.5 Otic (addisonlabs.com)|
|Clean N Dry (pinnaclifeanimalhealth.com)
MalAcetic Otic (dechra-us.com)
|Enzymes||Zymox Otic (petkingbrands.com)||
|Enrofloxacin||Baytril Otic (bayerdvm.com)||
Generic formulas: Betagen Otic (medpharmex.com)
|Silver sulfadiazine||Baytril Otic (bayerdvm.com)
Silvadene Cream (pfizer.com)
|Tromethamine (Tris) EDTA||Keto-Tris Flush (ceva.us)
Keto-Tris Flush PS (ceva.us)
Tris Flush (ceva.us)
Triz EDTA (dechra-us.com)
Triz EDTA Plus (dechra-us.com)
Triz Ultra + KETO (dechra-us.com)
T8 Keto (bayerdvm.com)
|Ketoconazole||Keto-Tris Flush (ceva.us)
Keto-Tris Flush PS (ceva.us)
Triz Ultra + KETO (dechra-us.com)
T8 Keto (bayerdvm.com)
Generic formula: Betagen Otic (medpharmex.com)
|Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO)||Synotic (zoetis.com)||
|Fluocinolone acetonide||Synotic (zoetis.com)||
|Hydrocortisone||Malacetic HC (dechra-us.com)
Medicated Ear Hydrogel (pinnaclifeanimalhealth.com)
Zymox Otic (petkingbrands.com)
|Hydrocortisone aceponate||Easotic (virbacvet.com)||
Topical antimicrobial therapy for active infections is imperative to success. The antimicrobial agent best utilized is initially often chosen empirically based on:
- Cytologic examination of ear canal exudate
- Otoscopic evaluation of the ear canal.
Several veterinary topical otic formulations contain antibacterial agents (Table 4).
The use of bacterial culture and sensitivity (C/S) of otic exudate to determine antibiotic selection is controversial.
The concentration of antibiotics in topical otic preparations is much higher than those tested at the laboratory to determine the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of any bacteria. Thus, some bacteria with a low MIC (that would usually be considered resistant) may actually prove to be sensitive to topical otic preparations. However, when the MIC is 0, complete bacterial resistance is likely, and use of an antimicrobial at any concentration against the resistant organism will not be helpful.
In general, C/S tends to be more useful when there is:
- Persistence of bacteria despite antibiotic therapy
- Middle ear involvement.2,3
When treating with antimicrobials:
- Use fluoroquinolones with caution against Staphylococcus species; reports demonstrate an increased likelihood of oxacillin-resistant bacteria development.8
- Consider pretreating the ear canal with a product containing tromethamine ethylenediaminetetraacetate (Tris EDTA) prior to administration of a topical antibiotic when addressing resistant bacterial infections, especially gram negative infections, such as Pseudomonas aeruginosa.
- Tris EDTA has both antibacterial properties and synergistic bactericidal activity with aminoglycosides and fluoroquinolones.
Silver sulfadiazine may be used instead of other antibiotics for treatment of some bacterial infections, although accumulation of medication debris in the ear canal may limit its long-term use. Newer generation colloidal silver-based products are now becoming available.
Malassezia pachydermatis is the most common isolate from diseased ears.2,4 Numerous products are available to address yeast otitis (Table 4). In many cases of mild allergic yeast otitis, decreasing otic inflammation with a topical glucocorticoid alone can resolve the infection.
- Thiabendazole, clotrimazole, and miconazole are used alone or, more commonly, in combination with a corticosteroid and antibiotic.
- Ketoconazole is available in combination with Tris EDTA.2,3,9
In chronic recurrent yeast otitis, the use of products that contain boric or acetic acid can be effective in preventing recurrence of infection.9
- Boric acid solutions are:
- Generally effective at managing chronic recurrent yeast otitis
- Effective in treating mild to moderate acute yeast otitis9
- Not apparently effective against bacterial organisms.
- Acetic acid solutions may markedly irritate the ear canal, especially at concentrations of 2% or higher.
The majority of antimicrobial topical formulations contain anti-inflammatory agents (Table 4), which aid in decreasing inflammation of the ear canal associated with:
- Primary ear disease
- Secondary infections.
Topical use of corticosteroids as anti-inflammatory agents is necessary to decrease inflammation and pain in the ear canal when treating otitis. Topical use is less likely to result in adverse clinical signs compared with systemic use; however, many commonly used corticosteroids, such as betamethasone and dexamethasone, have shown systemic absorption to some extent.10
Mometasone is a potent glucocorticoid that has minimal systemic absorption, making it potentially less of a concern for adrenal axis suppression; it also has longer residual effects, allowing for once daily therapy.
Hydrocortisone aceponate is converted to HC17 propionate, a highly active anti-inflammatory with potency equivalent to that of dexamethasone. Further, absorption through the skin and ear causes the drug to become deactivated, allowing it to be excreted without causing systemic effects.1
Hydrocortisone can potentially be used for chronic recurrent allergic otitis, but is not usually beneficial in acute, exudative, or proliferative otitis.2,3 Maintenance products containing hydrocortisone need to be selected on a case-by-case basis, depending on their efficacy in controlling inflammation.
Cases of chronic recurrent otitis are usually secondary to an inadequately controlled primary condition, which can result in damage to the ear canal lining and the normal physiologic mechanism for ear cleaning, further complicating the chronicity. Also, undiagnosed and/or uncontrolled otitis media can cause chronic otitis externa.
Preparations designed for long-term control are combinations of:
- Mild cleansers
- Drying agents or disinfectants
- Sometimes antimicrobial agents.
See Goals of Maintenance Therapy for further information.
C/S = culture and sensitivity; MIC = minimum inhibitory concentration; Tris EDTA = tromethamine ethylenediaminetetraacetate
- Wohlrab J, Beck GM, Neubert RH, et al. Hydrocortisone aceponate activity and benefit/risk ratio in relation to reference topical glucocorticoids. Skin Pharmacol Physiol 2010; 23(4):177-182.
- Mendelsohn CM. Topical antimicrobial for otitis. In Bonagura JD, Twedt DC (eds): Kirk’s Current Veterinary Dermatology XV. St. Louis: Elsevier, 2012, pp 462-465.
- Rosenkrantz WS, Mendelsohn CL. Dermatologic therapy. In Miller W, Griffin CE, Campbell K (eds): Muller and Kirk’s Small Animal Dermatology, 7th ed. St. Louis: Elsevier, 2013, pp 109-183.
- Morris DO. Medical therapy of otitis externa and otitis media. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract2004; 34(2):541-555.
- Saridomichelakis MN, Farmaki R, Leontides LS, Koutinas AF. Aetiology of canine otitis externa: A retrospective study of 100 cases. Vet Dermatol 2007; 18(5):341-347.
- Cole LK, Luu DH, Rajala-Schultz PJ, et al. In vitro activity of an ear rinse containing tromethamine, EDTA, benzyl alcohol and 0.1% ketoconazole on Malassezia organisms from dogs with otitis externa. Vet Dermatol 2007; 18(2):115-119.
- Gortel, K. Otic flushing. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 2004; 34(2):557-565.
- Morris DO, Rook KA, Shofer FS, Rankin SC. Screening of Staphylococcus aureus, Staphylococcus intermedius, and Staphylococcus schleiferi isolates obtained from small companion animals for antimicrobial resistance: A retrospective review of 749 isolates (2003-04). Vet Dermatol 2006; 17(5):332-337.
- Mendelsohn CL, Griffin CE, Rosenkrantz WS, et al. Efficacy of boric-complexed zinc and acetic-complexed zinc otic preparations for canine yeast otitis externa. JAAHA 2005; 41(1):12-21.
- Reeder CJ, Griffin CE, Polissar NL, et al. Comparative adrenocortical suppression in dogs with otitis externa following topical otic administration of four different glucocorticoid-containing medications. Vet Ther 2008; 9(2):111-121.