Resuscitative Fluid Therapy for Circulatory Shock
Deborah Silverstein, DVM, Diplomate ACVECC
Resuscitative fluid therapy commonly refers to the treatment of circulatory shock and utilizes intravenous fluids to help restore circulating blood volume.1,2
Shock is best defined as inadequate cellular energy production.3 When oxygen delivery (DO2) to the tissues is insufficient relative to tissue oxygen consumption (VO2), an energy deficit occurs. The Figure illustrates contributors to DO2 and portrays how inadequacy of any of these factors can lead to shock.
In 1972, Hinshaw and Cox proposed a classification scheme for shock.4 The main categories were:
- Hypovolemic: Inadequate circulating volume (eg, hemorrhage)
- Obstructive: Extracardiac obstruction of blood flow (eg, cardiac tamponade)
- Distributive: Maldistribution of blood flow and volume (eg, sepsis)
- Cardiogenic: Primary cardiac pump failure.
Newer shock classifications have been proposed but all of these can be included in 1 or more of the previous 4 categories and have yet to be universally accepted:
- Metabolic (eg, hypoglycemia, mitochondrial dysfunction)
- Endocrine (eg, hypoadrenocorticism, hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism)
- Hypoxemic (eg, severe anemia)
- Neurogenic (eg, spinal cord transection)
Consequences of Shock
Rapid progression of shock can be lethal due to major organ failure (eg, heart, brain). A more insidious progression causes cellular membrane dysregulation, which leads to:
- Exposure of subendothelial collagen
- Activation of platelets, clotting cascade, fibrinolytic, and kinin systems
- Bacterial translocation from the intestinal tract.
Subsequently, systemic inflammatory response, sepsis, and multiple organ dysfunctions often result. Despite adequate shock reversal, they may persist and can result in death.
Fluid Therapy Indications
To optimize the chance of a successful outcome, rapid, aggressive therapy and appropriate monitoring is warranted as soon as a state of shock is identified. While contraindicated for treatment of cardiogenic shock, intravenous fluid therapy is the cornerstone of treatment for hypovolemic and distributive shock.
Depending on the location of the obstruction, responsiveness to fluid therapy varies with obstructive forms of shock. Resuscitative fluid therapy can be attempted, but treatment of the underlying disorder is ultimately essential (ie, pericardiocentesis for pericardial effusion causing tamponade).
Types of Fluid Therapy
The arsenal of fluid types available for the treatment of shock comprises:
- Isotonic and hypertonic crystalloids
- Synthetic colloids
- Hemoglobin-based oxygen-carrying solutions
- Blood products.
The patient’s clinical condition and type of shock dictates which fluid type to employ and is further discussed in the following sections.
911 Notes: Resuscitative Fluid Therapy
- Fluid resuscitation is essential for the treatment of noncardiogenic circulatory shock and should be tailored to the patient’s clinical needs.
- A myriad of fluid types are available and can be used together to maximize their potential benefits.
- However, each fluid type also carries possible undesirable side effects that can lead to worsening of a patient’s well-being.
- Judicious fluid type and dosage choice along with close cardiovascular monitoring is key for safe fluid resuscitation.
Crystalloid fluids primarily consist of water combined with sodium, chloride, and/or glucose. Depending on the type of fluid, it may also contain other electrolytes, such as potassium and calcium, and buffers, such as lactate, acetate, and gluconate.
Based on the tonicity (effective osmolality) when compared to the extracellular fluid compartment, crystalloids are further subdivided into:
Isotonic crystalloids contain simple electrolytes (sodium and chloride) in proportions similar to that of plasma. Hence, they are also called replacement fluids. Examples include:
- 0.9% sodium chloride
- Lactated Ringer’s solution; contains potassium, calcium, and lactate as buffers
- Normosol-R (hospira.com) and Plasma-Lyte-A (baxter.com); both contain potassium, magnesium, acetate, and gluconate as buffers.
Isotonic crystalloids are the least expensive resuscitative fluids and are commonly used as the initial resuscitative fluid for the treatment of patients in fluid-responsive shock.
The empirical shock dosage is the equivalent of the patient’s blood volume: 90 mL/kg in the dog and 50 mL/kg in the cat.5 A common dosing approach consists of administering -+ to 1/3 of the shock dose; then reassessing the patient’s cardiovascular parameters prior to further administration.
Considerations & Precautions
These fluids rapidly redistribute into the extracellular compartment following administration and approximately 25% of the delivered volume remains in the vascular space 30 minutes postinfusion.6 While this is beneficial in dehydrated patients, overzealous use should be avoided to prevent volume overload and interstitial, pulmonary, or cerebral edema.
Furthermore, large volumes of isotonic crystalloids cause hemodilution of blood constituents and may lead to cardiac and pulmonary complications, gastrointestinal dysmotility, coagulation disturbances, and immunological and inflammatory mediator dysfunction.7
Because rapid intravasacular infusion of hypotonic fluids does not lead to a sustained intravascular volume increase but does lead to potentially dangerous changes in cellular osmolality, they are contraindicated as resuscitative fluids.
Hypertonic saline is a sodium chloride solution with an osmolality greater than the patient’s plasma osmolality. The usual concentration used for fluid resuscitation is approximately 7.5%, which has an osmolality of 2400 mOsm/L.
After rapid infusion, an osmotic gradient is created that draws water from the intracellular and interstitial space into the intravascular space. Therefore, the vascular volume expansion is greater than the infused volume (approximately 3 times greater).8,9
Hypertonic saline presents a good option for patients with traumatic brain injury or when rapid intravascular volume expansion is required. Additional benefits include increased cardiac contractility, mild peripheral arteriolar vasodilation and immunomodulatory effects.
Its use, however, is contraindicated in patients that are dehydrated, hyperosmolar, or hypokalemic and it is controversial in patients that have uncontrolled hemorrhage (eg, intracranial or intra-abdominal).10
The usual shock dosage of hypertonic saline is 4 to 7 mL/kg in dogs and 3 to 4 mL/kg in cats, administered over approximately 10 minutes. Infusion rates greater than 1 mL/kg/min may cause a vagally mediated bradycardia, vasodilation, and bronchoconstriction.
To prolong the intravascular volume expansion effect, a hypertonic saline/synthetic colloid mixture can be administered:
- 1:2.5 ratio of 23.4% sodium chloride:hetastarch = approximately 7.5% saline mixture (44 mL of 23.4% sodium chloride in 106 mL hydroxyethyl starch)
- It should be administered in small volumes (up to 5 mL/kg) over 5 to 10 minutes.
Considerations & Precautions
As with isotonic crystalloid solutions, the infused sodium chloride solution will ultimately equilibrate between the intravascular and interstitial space. In addition, the transient hyperosmolality will cause an osmotic diuresis.
The volume expanding effect lasts approximately 30 minutes8 and subsequent isotonic crystalloid infusion is required (see Dosing). As discussed above, concurrent colloid administration prolongs the volume effect and may be beneficial.
Dosing Details: Fluid Therapy
Shock dosage refers to the amount of fluid type required to reverse clinical manifestations of shock. The Table below offers a quick reference of total shock dosages for each of the commonly used fluid types. However, the dosage of fluid required to improve the cardiovascular status of each patient is variable and depends on the nature and severity of shock.
A prudent common clinical practice consists of:
- Administration of aliquots of the total empirical dose
- Rapid reassessment of cardiovascular parameters, such as:
- Heart rate & pulse quality
- Blood pressure
- Mucous membrane color
- Capillary refill time
- Urine output
- Blood lactate level.
- Administration of additional aliquots as needed until desired effect is reached.
*It is recommended that fluids are titrated to effect, often requiring less than the maximum doses listed.
Synthetic colloids are large molecules (molecular weight > 20 kilodaltons [kDa]) that do not readily escape across the capillary membrane if normal permeability is present. Synthetic colloids are suspended in isotonic crystalloid-base solutions. When infused IV, the macromolecules increase the oncotic pressure, resulting in fluid movement from the extravascular into the intravascular space.
Commercialized synthetic colloids include:
- Glucose polymers (dextran)
- Hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOC)
- Hydroxyethyl starches.
Glucose Polymers & Gelatins
Historically, the most commonly used and studied glucose polymer was Dextran 70; however, it is no longer commercially available. Gelatin solutions, a chemical modification of bovine collagen, have limited use due to their short duration of action and numerous side effects.
Hemoglobin-Based Oxygen Carriers
HBOC solutions may be beneficial in animals with severe anemia because they increase oxygen delivery to the tissues. HBOC may also increase perfusion of capillary beds with microvascular thrombosis due to the small size of free hemoglobin.
Considerations & Precautions
Despite the aforementioned potential benefits of HBOC and its long shelf life, it is not widely used due to inconsistent supply, undesirable side effects, and lack of clear benefit over natural blood products.
Hydroxyethyl starches are composed of amylopectin polymers with specific chemical modifications that dictate their pharmacokinetics and elimination.
Commercially available hydroxyethyl starch products differ by their concentration, average molecular weight, and degree of substitution (see The Finer Features of Hydroxyethyl Starches) and include:
Although the use of hydroxyethyl starches alone have no proven benefit over the use of crystalloid solutions alone for the treatment of fluid responsive shock, they remain a good adjunct treatment, especially in patients with low colloid osmotic pressure or increased vascular permeability.
The recommended shock dose of hetastarch is up to 20 mL/kg in dogs and up to 10 mL/kg in cats. A common practice consists of administering increments of -+ to -+ of the total shock dose, followed by reassessment of cardiovascular parameters.
Considerations & Precautions
Use of hydroxyethyl starches may lead to:
- Fluid overload and hemodilution (associated with large infused volumes)
- Coagulation abnormalities due to decreased coagulation factors VIII and von Willebrand, thrombocytopathia, and increased fibrin clot fragility.12
Although not contraindicated in patients with coagulopathies, caution should be exercised. Renal impairment and allergic reactions have been reported in people, but not small animals.13,14,15
Crystalloids & Colloids: Their Rapport
Synthetic Colloids versus Hypertonic Saline
- With synthetic colloid administration, intravascular volume expansion is greater than the infused volume, which is similar to hypertonic saline.
- However, contrary to hypertonic saline administration, mobilized fluid volume remains in the vascular space due to sustained increase in oncotic pressure.
Crystalloids & Colloids in Unison
- Both synthetic colloids and hypertonic saline achieve a rapid increase in intravascular volume and are often combined to prolong the benefit of hypertonic saline.11
- Additionally, synthetic colloids are often used in conjunction with isotonic crystalloids to help retain the infused volume in the intravascular space, reducing the crystalloid volume required for resuscitation.
Fresh whole blood contains all the elements of blood:
- Red blood cells
- Coagulation factors
- White blood cells
The separation of red blood cells and plasma provides various blood component products that allows for longer preservation of the units and more specific therapy. The product type should be tailored to the patient’s needs.
Packed Red Blood Cells
Packed red blood cell transfusion is indicated in patients with acute anemia (hematocrit < 25%) and persistent clinical cardiovascular instability.16
Packed red blood cells can be administered at a dose of 10 to 15 mL/kg to raise the hematocrit by 10%.
Fresh Frozen Plasma
Fresh frozen plasma is indicated to replenish coagulation factors in patients with prolonged coagulation times. However, despite being a source of albumin, its colloidal effect is limited due to its relatively low concentration compared to synthetic colloids.
Fresh frozen plasma can be administered at a dose of 10 to 15 mL/kg.
Fresh Whole Blood
Fresh whole blood provides the benefits of both previously mentioned products (packed red blood cells and fresh frozen plasma) but is also a source of platelets, which is beneficial in patients with:
- Severe thrombocytopenia or thrombocytopathia-induced bleeding
- Massive blood loss
- Severely thrombocytopenic patient in need of surgery.
Fresh whole blood is administered at a dose of 20 to 25 mL/kg. Ideally, blood-typing and cross-matching are performed before any blood product transfusion.
In addition, when time allows, any blood product should be infused over 1 to 4 hours to allow for adverse reaction monitoring. However, faster administration may be warranted in patients with severe ongoing hemorrhage until hemostasis can be achieved.
Considerations & Precautions
Potential adverse events associated with transfusion therapy include:
- Acute or delayed immunologic reactions
- Electrolyte imbalances (ie, hypocalcemia, hypomagnesemia, hyperkalemia)
- Transmission of infectious agents.
Another major disadvantage of blood products is their associated cost and limited availability as compared to other types of resuscitative fluids.
The Finer Features of Hydroxyethyl Starches
Concentration: Most hydroxyethyl starch solutions have a concentration of 6%.
Molecular Weight: The weight average molecular weight is categorized into:
- Low molecular weight (70 kDa)
- Medium molecular weight (130-270 kDa)
- High molecular weight (450 kDa).
Degree of Substitution: The degree of substitution refers to the number of hydroxyethyl groups per molecule. A higher degree of substitution confers a longer half-life.
- Historically, it was suggested that molecules of less than 200 kDa, with a degree of substitution less than 0.4, may plug capillary endothelial pores, subsequently decreasing their permeability.
- However, more recent data suggest that hydroxyethyl starches may down regulate adhesion molecule expression, inhibit neutrophil recruitment, and minimize pro-inflammatory cytokine production.12
Overview of Therapy
An Overview of Resuscitative Fluid Therapy table is available below.
DO2 = oxygen delivery;
HBOC = hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers;
kDa = kilodalton; VO2 = oxygen consumption
- Parkins WN, Perlmutt JH, Vars HM. Evaluation of crystalloidal solutions in hemorrhaged dogs. Amer J Physiol 1952; 170:351.
- Fogelman MJ, Wilson BJ. A different concept of volume replacement in traumatic hypovolemia observations on injured man and animal. Amer J Surg 1960; 99(5):694-701.
- Chaudry IH. Cellular mechanisms in shock and ischemia and their correction. Amer J Physiol 1983; 245(2):R117-R134.
- Hinshaw LB, Cox BG (eds). The 50 Fundamental Mechanisms of Shock. New York City: Plenum Press, 1972, p 13.
- Day TK, Bateman S. Shock syndromes. In DiBartola SP (ed): Fluid, Electrolyte, and Acid-Base Disorders in Small Animal Practice, 3rd ed. St. Louis: Elsevier, 2006, pp 540-564.
- Griffel MI, Kaufman BS. Pharmacology of colloids and crystalloids. Crit Care Clin 1992; 8(2):235-253.
- Cotton BA, Guy JS, Morris JA Jr, Abumrad NN. The cellular, metabolic, and systemic consequences of aggressive fluid resuscitation strategies. Shock 2006; 26(2):115-121.
- Silverstein DC, Aldrich J, Haskins S, et al. Assessment of changes in blood volume in response to resuscitative fluid administration in dogs. J Vet Emerg Crit Care 2005; 15(3):185-192.
- Kramer GC. Hypertonic resuscitation: Physiologic mechanisms and recommendations for trauma care. Trauma 2003; 54(5):S89-S99.
- Krausz MM. Controversies in shock research: Hypertonic resuscitation—pros and cons. Shock 1995; 3(1):69-72.
- Smith GJ, Kramer GC, Perron PR, et al. A comparison of several hypertonic solutions for resuscitation of bled sheep. J Surg Re 1985; 39:517-528.
- Chan DL. Colloids: Current recommendations. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 2008; 38(3):587-593.
- Niemi TT, Miyashita R, Yamakage M. Colloid solutions: A clinical update. J Anes 2010; 24(6):913-925.
- Grundmann U, Heinzmann A, Schwering L, et al. Diagnostic approach identifying hydroxyethyl starch (HES) triggering a severe anaphylactic reaction during anesthesia in a 15-year-old boy. Klinische Padiatrie 2010; 222(7):469-470.
- Ring J, Messmer K. Incidence and severity of anaphylactoid reactions to colloid volume substitutes. Lancet 1977; 1(8009):466-469.
- De Laforcade AM, Silverstein DC. Shock. In Silverstein DC, Hopper K (eds): Small Animal Critical Care Medicine, 1st ed. St. Louis: Elsevier, 2009, pp 41-45.