The Protein Paradigm: Assessing Dietary Protein in Health & Disease
Justin Shmalberg, DVM, Diplomate ACVN & ACVSMR
University of Florida
The American College of Veterinary Nutrition (acvn.org) and Today’s Veterinary Practice are delighted to bring you the Nutrition Notes column, which provides the highest quality, cutting edge information on companion animal nutrition, provided by the ACVN’s foremost nutrition specialists.
The primary objectives of the ACVN are to:
- Advance the specialty area of veterinary nutrition
- Increase the competence of those practicing in this field
- Establish requirements for certification in veterinary nutrition
- Encourage continuing education for both specialists and general practitioners
- Promote evidence-based research
- Enhance dissemination of the latest veterinary nutrition knowledge.
The ACVN achieves these objectives in many ways, including designating specialists in animal nutrition, providing continuing education through several media, supporting veterinary nutrition residency programs, and offering a wide array of resources related to veterinary nutrition, such as this column.
Dietary protein is one of 3 primary metabolic fuels of the body that, together with fat and carbohydrates, provides cellular energy. Amino acids extracted from dietary proteins are also used by animals to synthesize the functional proteins required for normal physiologic functions.
Proteins, produced by combining amino acids, are unique energy sources because they contain nitrogen, which can be used to interconvert amino acids or synthesize other nonprotein molecules, such as nucleic acids. Excess nitrogen liberated from protein processing must be eliminated to avoid toxicity.
Dietary amino acids are required for life and influence a number of conditions seen in veterinary patients, such as renal disease, liver failure, and urolithiasis.
THE FOUNDATION: PROTEIN
Body protein is composed of 20 different amino acids, which are linked together in long chains with peptide bonds. Proteins display complex structures, which serve a number of physiologic and biochemical processes, including:
- Cell signaling (eg, cytokines, hormones)
- Muscle contraction (eg, cardiac contraction, locomotion)
- Oxygen and nutrient transport in the blood, plus oncotic support (eg, hemoglobin, albumin, ceruloplasmin)
- Critical reactions, such as those involved in cellular transport, enzymes, and energy production.
BUILDING BLOCKS: AMINO ACIDS
Animals have amino acid requirements rather than intact protein requirements, which has been demonstrated in studies in which dogs and cats have been sustained on diets containing only purified amino acids in required amounts.
Amino acids are absorbed in the gastrointestinal tract following disruption of peptide bonds by pepsin, trypsin, chymotrypsin, and peptidases. Cells use active transport to obtain amino acids from the plasma and, subsequently, convert them to cell, tissue, or plasma proteins in target tissues.
Amino Acid Structure
Amino acids found in tissue proteins contain an amine (nitrogen-containing) group and a carboxylic acid group linked by a carbon, known as the alpha-carbon (Figure). Structures of amino acids differ in their side chains, which are attached to the alpha-carbon.
Commercial diets sold interstate must meet or exceed the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO, aafco.org) recommended amounts of crude protein and each essential amino acid.1
Essential amino acids cannot be synthesized and, therefore, must be present in the diet; humans, dogs, and cats need 9, 10, and 11 essential amino acids in the diet, respectively (Table 1).2 Nonessential amino acids in crude protein can provide nitrogen sources for biosynthetic pathways.
Limiting amino acids are those amino acids present in a food in the lowest amounts with regard to what the animal requires. These amino acids can adversely affect efficiency of protein utilization and the amount of protein synthesis that occurs.2 In pet foods, methionine and lysine are often the limiting amino acids.
Excess amino acids can be used for fuel and are divided into glucogenic and ketogenic amino acids depending on whether they can be used to produce glucose or acetyl coenzyme A, respectively.
In many pet foods, especially those with lower protein content, taurine is added, but it is only essential in cats because, in dogs, enzymatic conversion of cysteine to taurine is more active. Deficiency most notably causes dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs and cats and central retinal degeneration in cats.3
While some species reduce food intake when fed an amino-acid deficient diet, cats are a notable exception, presumably because their evolutionary prey were never limiting in protein.
Protein and essential amino acids can be derived from animal or plant sources.
Meats refer to striated muscle from mammals and can contain other surrounding tissue, such as fat or skin. Muscle meat contains a large concentration of protein, but substantial amounts can also be found in other products, such as organ tissues.
Most pet foods rely on parts of the animal that are not destined for human consumption, and ingredients listed as a general descriptor, such as chicken or beef, need not contain the whole animal but rather selected parts. For example, poultry or chicken, if listed on a label, refers to the clean combination of flesh and skin with or without accompanying bone, derived from parts or whole carcasses of poultry.1
Some more expensive canned diets are marketed as containing prime cuts of meat (eg, chicken breast, sirloin), but current labeling guidelines make such claims difficult to evaluate.
A meat meal refers to a product that contains similar inclusions as meats but is rendered and dried to contain minimal moisture. Meals are typically slightly higher in protein than meats, and generally provide more calories by weight than fresh meat; therefore, their appearance first on an ingredient list suggests that they may provide the primary source of calories in the food, which may not be the case for meats.
Plant proteins can provide digestible protein and amino acids. Many cereal grains are processed to produce starch, fat, and gluten. Gluten is the protein containing fraction of grains.
Vegetable proteins may be beneficial for reducing nitrogenous waste, with implications for hepatic encephalopathy and urate stones.4
Animal proteins are generally more digestible than plant proteins. However, this is not always the case; for example, corn gluten can have better availability than lamb meal.5 Fish, casein (a dairy protein), and egg are animal proteins that often display the highest digestibility.
Digestibility of animal products depends on the:
- Animal from which it is derived
- Part(s) of the carcass used
- Cooking temperature and pressure.
Digestibility of protein is both difficult to assess from information found on food labels and to measure because typical methods are not able to separate digestibility by the animal versus that of intestinal bacteria.
Atwater factors are used in human nutrition to predict the amount of energy in a certain mass of food. These factors assume a certain digestibility and reflect the anticipated amount of energy that is actually available after energetic losses in the urine and feces. The value used for many foods consumed by humans is 4 kilocalories (kcal) per gram of protein.2
AAFCO uses a modified factor of 3.5 kcal per gram for commercial pet foods, as it is assumed that extruded pet foods have reduced digestibility.1 Fortunately, most foods contain excess amino acids and crude protein due to the difficulty of precisely measuring protein digestibility.
Concerns with Glutens
While gluten free is a common label in human foods, true gluten sensitivity appears to be rare in dogs and cats, but has been documented in certain lines of Irish setters. Adverse effects from long-term gluten exposure in domestic animals have not been documented in scientific studies.
In addition, owners may express concern about plant proteins due to recalls in response to melamine contamination of wheat gluten-containing foods.6
PROTEIN MODIFICATION FOR LIFE STAGES
Requirements for dietary amino acids present in protein are well established for various life stages and types of animals:
- Growth, lactation, and late gestation increase protein and amino acid requirements, primarily due to increased biosynthetic reactions (Table 2).
- Cats (obligate carnivores) have higher protein requirements than dogs (omnivores).
- Performance animals may require elevated dietary concentrations of protein.7
- Senior dogs have nearly double the protein turnover of younger dogs and may require increased dietary protein due to decreased muscle anabolism and, perhaps, decreased protein digestibility or conversion.8
Protein modification has been suggested for weight loss, renal disease, urolithiasis, liver failure, food allergy, and other conditions. However, no evidence exists that protein restriction in healthy, older dogs prevents disease.8
CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS OF DIETARY PROTEIN
The nutritional needs for exercise and performance in dogs are well established. Less is known about cats as they infrequently perform vigorous exercise in competitive situations.
Dogs utilize adenosine triphosphate and carbohydrate reserves for initial bursts of energy; then rely on fat for endurance.2 Excess protein is used for energy and does not increase body stores. Protein catabolism acts as a reserve of substrates for gluconeogenesis and ketogenesis. Leucine administration, however, may help prevent muscle catabolism.9
Considerations for performance dogs include:
- Sprinting dogs and most agility dogs do not require more protein than that found in most moderate protein diets (60–90 g/1000 kcal)
- Endurance dogs likely require around 75 g/1000 kcal protein, based on limited studies7
- High protein, low carbohydrate diets may impair performance in some cases.7
Diets with elevated amounts of protein are recommended for both overweight cats and dogs. Many veterinary diets for weight loss are formulated with increased protein (> 90 g/1000 kcal). Diets for weight management or maintenance without increased protein are not appropriate for weight loss protocols.
High protein diets are associated with:
- Increased palatability: Cats show a preference for high protein diets, while dogs prefer protein over carbohydrates when fat is reduced10
- Preservation of lean body mass (during weight loss)11
- Prevention of deficiencies associated with limiting amino acids (when calories are significantly restricted)
- Dietary thermogenesis: Cats had higher energy expenditure when a greater number of calories came from protein12 and, in a separate study, were able to consume 10% more food during a weight loss protocol.13
Cats display metabolic adaptations consistent with an obligate carnivore:
- Higher protein requirements
- Increased insulin response to amino acids
- Lack of sweet taste receptors
- Limited downregulation of gluconeogenesis
- Requirement for preformed taurine.2
Cats prefer a high dietary protein content (130 g/1000 kcal), which is consistent with diets of feral cats and the composition of rodents.10,14,15 Cats do, however, efficiently absorb and utilize dietary carbohydrates in amounts commonly found in pet foods.16 Long-term comparisons of cats fed diets with different concentrations of protein and carbohydrates are not available.
While high protein diets may improve diabetic control or remission,17 there is no association between high carbohydrate diets and obesity, the main risk factor for feline diabetes.18
Lower Urinary Tract Disease
Many therapeutic diets for lower urinary tract diseases are restricted in dietary protein. The evidence for such an approach varies by condition.
Canine struvite uroliths are almost always a product of infection; protein restriction has been used in canine struvite dissolution diets to reduce urea, a substrate for urease-positive bacteria.19
Feline struvite uroliths include the component ammonia; protein sources contain both phosphorus and nitrogen, which contribute to struvite formation. Therefore, lower protein diets may be associated with reduced sterile struvite risk in cats.20 Struvite crystals, in the absence of uroliths, are rarely an indication for dietary modification.
Calcium oxalate urolith recurrence was historically managed with reduced dietary protein given suggestions that protein promotes calcium excretion. However, higher levels of dietary protein reduced risk in dogs and cats, which may be due to increased water intake, urine output, and phosphorus excretion.20-22
Cystine uroliths form in dogs with a genetic defect in the renal tubules. Protein restriction reduces cysteine, but animals may also have increased loss of other amino acids and carnitine;23 therefore, definitive recommendations are not available.
Urate uroliths are a product of abnormal purine metabolism, and urate urolithiasis is prevented by purine, rather than protein and amino acid, restriction. While the purine concentration of most commercial diets is not reported, therapeutic diets for urate stones generally restrict dietary purine.
Feline lower urinary tract disease is associated with several conditions, and the role of protein is unclear for many of them. However, some authors now recommend moderate to high protein diets (> 75 g/1000 kcal) because they increase water intake, urine production, and urine acidification.24
Blood urea nitrogen (BUN), an unreliable marker of glomerular filtration rate (GFR), is influenced by dietary protein because ammonia is liberated during amino acid processing; then it is converted to BUN, a nontoxic product, in the liver. Urea itself does not contribute to renal disease but rather serves as a marker of uremic toxins.
High protein diets increase BUN in both healthy animals and those affected by kidney disease; therefore, protein restriction for canine and feline renal disease is a well-accepted practice. However, the optimal amount of protein to feed animals with either kidney disease or proteinuria is unknown, and there is no substantial evidence that protein is directly toxic to renal tubules in dogs as it appears to be in humans and rats.25
Protein content of a pet food is correlated with dietary phosphorus concentration, and some proteins contain more phosphorus per unit of protein than others (Table 3). Hyperphosphatemia reduces survival in animals with renal disease and is associated with renal secondary hyperparathyroidism;26,27 therefore, in dogs with experimental kidney disease, diets containing elevated protein, but reduced phosphorus, were as beneficial as those with reduced protein and phosphorus.28
Commercial renal diets provide more protein (25–55 g/1000 kcal for canine diets) than the recommended allowance for adult dogs (ie, > 25 g/1000 kcal).2
- When consumed in appropriate amounts, they should not cause amino acid deficiencies.
- Dogs and cats fed these diets have median survival times 2× greater than those fed maintenance diets.26,29,30 However, diets also contain reduced phosphorus and other modifications compared with maintenance diets.
- Most renal diets, however, do not meet the AAFCO standard for adult maintenance (51 g/1000 kcal)1 and, therefore, are sold only by veterinary recommendation.
Commercial maintenance foods contain added phosphorus and are, therefore, generally not appropriate for dogs and cats with renal disease.
Home-prepared diets are often used to increase protein, while maintaining reduced phosphorus, when the patient’s condition dictates such an approach.
Some senior and other therapeutic diets have lower phosphorus concentrations (1–2 g/1000 kcal) than many adult maintenance diets, but these concentrations are still higher than those of most therapeutic renal diets (< 1 g/1000 kcal). These diets may be used in select situations.
Additional considerations for feeding pets with renal disease include:
- Renal diets lower urine protein-to-creatinine ratio by reducing protein concentration reaching the glomerulus.
- These diets may cause a mild reduction in systolic blood pressure in dogs concurrently treated with benazepril.31
- Renal diets shown to prolong survival also contain omega-3 fatty acids, which can modulate GFR,32 but it is unclear which combination of dietary factors is contributory to the positive effects.
- Many practitioners try to reduce BUN in renal disease patients, but if this is done by severe protein restriction (< 20 g/1000 kcal), protein malnutrition may result, causing increased morbidity or mortality.25
Protein modification is required in the subset of liver disease patients with liver failure characterized by hyperammonemia and hepatic encephalopathy (HE).
- Liver failure is best assessed by a combination of direct (ammonia, bile acids) and indirect (albumin, cholesterol, BUN, bilirubin, and glucose) function tests; elevated liver enzymes alone do not warrant protein restriction.
- A reduction in urea cycle activity is responsible for HE; the nitrogen liberated from normal protein processing is not converted to the less toxic by-product, urea.
Protein restriction to about 40 g/1000 kcal has been suggested for HE.4 Feeding increased branched chain amino acids with decreased aromatic amino acids has also been suggested for HE, but past studies in dogs did not support this intervention.33
Vegetable-based protein may reduce the signs of HE, possibly due to increased small intestinal digestibility and reduced bacterial fermentation in the colon, which reduces the bacterial contribution to blood ammonia levels.4
Food allergy should be distinguished from food intolerance. A true allergy generally occurs to a specific protein or proteins present within the diet, and both meat and plant proteins have been reported to cause hypersensitivity.
- No evidence exists that protein restriction reduces allergic signs. If protein is restricted in a diet formulated for diet trials, it is likely because of the cost of the protein or hydrolysate used.
- Novel protein diets should not be antigenic, but cross-reactivity is possible and contamination of some limited ingredient diets has been reported.34
- Hydrolyzed diets contain proteins, usually poultry or soy, exposed to a chemical process to disrupt their structure and antigenicity. The molecular weight of the resulting fragments may correlate to antigenicity, and such diets are used for food allergies and chronic enteropathies.35
Specific nutritional recommendations for renal disease will be discussed in greater detail in an upcoming issue of Today’s Veterinary Practice.
Pet diets should be carefully evaluated for adequacy of amino acids. Fortunately, most commercial diets following AAFCO standards exceed the needs for most dogs and cats, making deficiency unlikely. Home-prepared diets, however, should be evaluated closely for adequacy. Taurine deficiency is the most notable clinical presentation in protein-deficient animals.
The protein content of foods should also be carefully assessed on a caloric basis when diets are evaluated for weight loss, performance, aging, chronic renal disease, HE, and some forms of urolithiasis. A detailed analysis of amino acid requirements may be required in complex conditions or in animals that consume lower amounts of food than expected.
AAFCO = Association of American Feed Control Officials; BUN = blood urea nitrogen; GFR = glomerular filtration rate; HE = hepatic encephalopathy; kcal = kilocalories
- AAFCO. 2015 AAFCO Official Publication. Champaign, IL: AAFCO, 2015.
- National Research Council. Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2006.
- Sanderson SL. Taurine and carnitine in canine cardiomyopathy. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 2006; 36(6):1325-1343.
- Proot S, Biourge V, Teske E, Rothuizen J. Soy protein isolate versus meat-based low-protein diet for dogs with congenital portosystemic shunts. J Vet Intern Med 2009; 23(4):794-800.
- Johnson ML, Parsons CM, Fahey GC Jr, et al. Effects of species raw material source, ash content, and processing temperature on amino acid digestibility of animal by-product meals by cecectomized roosters and ileally cannulated dogs. J Anim Sci 1998; 76(4):1112-1122.
- Brown CA, Jeong KS, Poppenga RH, et al. Outbreaks of renal failure associated with melamine and cyanuric acid in dogs and cats in 2004 and 2007. J Vet Diagn Invest 2007; 19(5):525-531.
- Wakshlag JJ, Shmalberg J. Nutrition for working and service dogs. Vet Clin North Am Small Pract 2014; 44(4):719-740.
- Wannemacher R, McCoy J. Determination of optimal dietary protein requirements in young and old dogs. J Nutr 1966; 88(1):66-74.
- Kimball SR, Jefferson LS. Signaling pathways and molecular mechanisms through which branched-chain amino acids mediate translational control of protein synthesis. J Nutr 2006; 136(1):227S-231S.
- Hewson-Hughes AK, Hewson-Hughes VL, Miller AT, et al. Geometric analysis of macronutrient selection in the adult domestic cat, Felis catus. J Exp Biol 2011; 214(Pt 6):1039-1051.
- Roudebush P, Schoenherr WD, Delaney SJ. An evidence-based review of the use of therapeutic foods, owner education, exercise, and drugs for the management of obese and overweight pets. JAVMA 2008; 233(5):717-725.
- Wei A, Fascetti AJ, Liu KJ, et al. Influence of a high-protein diet on energy balance in obese cats allowed ad libitum access to food. J Anim Physiol Anim Nutr (Berl) 2011; 95(3):359-367.
- Vasconcellos RS, Borges NC, Gonçalves KN, et al. Protein intake during weight loss influences the energy required for weight loss and maintenance in cats. J Nutr 2009; 139(5):855-860.
- Dierenfeld E, Alcorn H, Jacobsen K. Nutrient Composition of Whole Vertebrate Prey (Excluding Fish) Fed in Zoos. Beltsville, MD: USDA Animal Welfare Information Center, 2002.
- Plantinga EA, Bosch G, Hendriks WH. Estimation of the dietary nutrient profile of free-roaming feral cats: Possible implications for nutrition of domestic cats. Br J Nutr 2011; 106(1):S35-S48.
- Verbrugghe A, Hesta M, Daminet S, Janssens GP. Nutritional modulation of insulin resistance in the true carnivorous cat: A review. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 2012; 52(2):172-182.
- Nack R, DeClue AE. In cats with newly diagnosed diabetes mellitus, use of a near-euglycemic management paradigm improves remission rate over a traditional paradigm. Vet Q 2014; 34(3):132-136.
- Nelson RW, Reusch CE. Animal models of disease: Classification and etiology of diabetes in dogs and cats. J Endocrinol 2014; 222(3):T1-T9.
- Osborne CA, Polzin DJ, Kruger JM, et al. Medical dissolution of canine struvite uroliths. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 1986; 16(2):349-374.
- Lekcharoensuk C, Osborne CA, Lulich JP, et al. Association between dietary factors and calcium oxalate and magnesium ammonium phosphate urolithiasis in cats. JAVMA 2001; 219(9):1228-1237.
- Lekcharoensuk C, Osborne CA, Lulich JP, et al. Associations between dry dietary factors and canine calcium oxalate uroliths. Am J Vet Res 2002; 63(3):330-337.
- Lekcharoensuk C, Osborne CA, Lulich JP, et al. Associations between dietary factors in canned food and formation of calcium oxalate uroliths in dogs. Am J Vet Res 2002; 63(2):163-169.
- Sanderson SL, Osborne CA, Lulich JP, et al. Evaluation of urinary carnitine and taurine excretion in 5 cystinuric dogs with carnitine and taurine deficiency. J Vet Intern Med 2001; 15(2):94-100.
- Kerr KR. Companion animals symposium: Dietary management of feline lower urinary tract symptoms. J Anim Sci 2013; 91(6):2965-2975.
- Burkholder WJ, Lees GE, LeBlanc AK, et al. Diet modulates proteinuria in heterozygous female dogs with X-linked hereditary nephropathy. J Vet Intern Med 2004; 18(2):165-175.
- Elliott DA. Nutritional management of chronic renal disease in dogs and cats. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 2006; 36(6):1377-1384, viii.
- Ross LA, Finco DR, Crowell WA. Effect of dietary phosphorus restriction on the kidneys of cats with reduced renal mass. Am J Vet Res 1982;43(6):1023-1026.
- Finco DR, Brown SA, Crowell WA, et al. Effects of dietary phosphorus and protein in dogs with chronic renal failure. Am J Vet Res 1992; 53(12):2264-2271.
- Jacob F, Polzin DJ, Osborne CA, et al. Clinical evaluation of dietary modification for treatment of spontaneous chronic renal failure in dogs. JAVMA 2002; 220(8):1163-1170.
- Ross SJ, Osborne CA, Kirk CA, et al. Clinical evaluation of dietary modification for treatment of spontaneous chronic kidney disease in cats. JAVMA 2006; 229(6):949-957.
- Cortadellas O, Talavera J, Fernández del Palacio MJ. Evaluation of the effects of a therapeutic renal diet to control proteinuria in proteinuric non-azotemic dogs treated with benazepril. J Vet Intern Med 2014; 28(1):30-37.
- Brown SA, Brown CA, Crowell WA, et al. Beneficial effects of chronic administration of dietary omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids in dogs with renal insufficiency. J Lab Clin Med 1998; 131(5):447-455.
- Meyer HP, Chamuleau RA, Legemate DA, et al. Effects of a branched-chain amino acid-enriched diet on chronic hepatic encephalopathy in dogs. Metab Brain Dis 1999; 14(2):103-115.
- Willis-Mahn C, Remillard R, Tater K. ELISA testing for soy antigens in dry dog foods used in dietary elimination trials. JAAHA 2014; 50(6):383-389.
- Mandigers PJ, Biourge V, van den Ingh TS, et al. A randomized, open-label, positively-controlled field trial of a hydrolyzed protein diet in dogs with chronic small bowel enteropathy. J Vet Intern Med 2010; 24(6):1350-1357.